"Rosenthal and Brookmeyer's One Night in Vermont is a stunning album complete with all of jazz beloved nuances." - Celeste Sunderland, All About Jazz
"Brookmeyer and Rosenthal spread mood, melody and warmth throughout… one of the best jazz albums of the year (2004)." - Owen Cordle, Raleigh News and Observer
"Brookmeyer is in top latter-day form and Rosenthal -- an ideal partner harmonically and rhythmically -- is a very tasty, inventive soloist. One of the most human recordings I've heard in a long time - there are two souls up there, talking and singing." -- Larry Kart